Draftweft / Field notes

How to Check a Short Story Against a Literary Magazine’s Word Limit

Contents
AI-generated illustration; not taken on location · An illustrated manuscript with a pencil and word-count notes.
AI-generated illustration; not taken on location · An illustration of a manuscript and word-count notes.AI-generated illustration

To check whether your short story meets a literary magazine’s word limit, first find the instructions for the category and submission window you intend to enter. Then count the text the magazine says to include and compare the result with any minimum and maximum. After making changes, repeat the check on the version you will submit.

A reliable check involves more than looking at one number. A magazine may explain which accompanying material belongs in the count or specify how to measure it. If those instructions are unclear, identify the uncertainty before you submit. The steps below will help you work through the decision, make any necessary edits, and keep track of the final total.

Find the limit that applies to your submission

Start with the magazine’s current submission guidance and look for the category that fits your story. Read the requirements for the relevant submission window as well as any general instructions. Record the minimum, if there is one, and the maximum, along with any explanation of what the magazine includes in its count.

If a magazine offers more than one category, check the range for the one you plan to select. A limit associated with a different category may not be useful for your submission. Likewise, check whether the guidance for your intended window gives a separate instruction. If you cannot tell which category applies, clarify that question before editing toward a particular number.

Make a small working note

Write down the category, the applicable range, and any specified counting method in one place. Also note instructions about the title, author details, or other text if the magazine provides them. Keeping these details beside your draft makes it easier to repeat the check after revisions.

For example, imagine a category with a stated range of 1,000 to 3,000 words. Those numbers are only an illustration; use the actual range in the guidance for your submission. A story measured at 2,400 words would fall within that example range, provided the measurement covers the text the magazine requires.

Do not use the number of manuscript pages as a substitute for the requested word count. Formatting and dialogue can change the relationship between word count and printed page count, so a page total does not by itself settle whether the story meets a word limit.

Decide what text to count

Before opening a counter, identify the beginning and end of the text you need to measure. The story itself is the starting point, but accompanying material may need separate attention. Check the magazine’s instructions for the title, author information, notes, and anything else you plan to send with the story.

If the guidance says to include a particular item, include it when you measure the text. If it says to exclude an item, leave it out of the measured selection. Do not assume that a title or a note is included merely because it appears in the same document as the story; follow the magazine’s wording.

A useful way to prepare is to make a temporary copy of the material to be counted. Check the beginning and end of that copy against the original, and make sure you have included all of the story. If you are removing material from the copy for counting purposes, keep your submission draft intact so you do not accidentally omit something the magazine asks you to provide.

What if the instructions are unclear?

Write down the specific question before seeking clarification. For example: “Should the story’s title be included in the word count?” If several items are uncertain, list them individually so the answer can address each one. Use any contact or clarification process the magazine provides.

While waiting for an answer, you can measure the story both with and without the disputed material to understand how much the uncertainty matters. Label each result clearly. Neither result resolves the question of what the magazine requires, but the comparison can help you decide whether an answer is needed before you finalize your submission.

Count the story and compare the result

Once you know what to include, select that text and paste it into a word counter. Read the word total and record it beside the magazine’s range. If the magazine specifies a counting program or method, check the result using those instructions; do not assume every counter will produce the same total.

Before relying on the number, check the pasted text. Look at its first and last lines, confirm that the complete story is present, and verify that any required accompanying text is included. If you pasted from a temporary copy, make sure it represents the draft you intend to submit.

Compare the total with both boundaries

Use the magazine’s stated minimum and maximum when deciding what the result means. For an illustrative range of 1,000 to 3,000 words, the comparison might look like this:

Measured total Comparison Next step
900 words 100 below the example minimum Consider whether the story needs more development.
2,400 words Within the example range Recheck after any further edits.
3,100 words 100 above the example maximum Look for cuts that preserve the story’s essentials.

These figures are examples, not recommended limits. Replace them with the magazine’s requirements and your own measured total. If the instructions state exactly how a boundary applies, follow that wording when your count is at the boundary.

If your result is close to either boundary, leave enough room to account for any uncertainty you have not yet resolved. In particular, confirm the required text and any specified method before treating a close result as final. If two counts differ, check that both measurements used the same text before investigating punctuation or other possible causes.

Review punctuation and revise if needed

If counts differ, or if your story is close to a boundary, inspect places where words are joined and where you use hyphens or dashes. Check whether the magazine explains how such text should be treated or names a counting method. If the instructions do not answer the question and the difference could affect eligibility, seek clarification rather than relying on an assumption about how the magazine counts.

Do not change punctuation solely to produce a preferred number without checking that the change still serves the sentence. Read the passage in context and retain the wording and punctuation that communicate what you intend, subject to the magazine’s instructions.

Edit toward the required range

If the story is too long, start by looking for passages that repeat information or delay a necessary action without adding something you want the reader to understand. Consider whether a sentence, exchange, or description can be shortened while keeping its purpose clear. Make deliberate cuts rather than removing words at random to reach a target.

If the story is too short, look for places where a reader needs more context, a transition, or a meaningful development. Add material because it strengthens the story, not simply to increase the total. If expansion would weaken the piece, consider whether another suitable submission category is available and check its requirements.

After each substantial round of edits, count the applicable text again. Compare the new total with both boundaries and read the revised passages in context. A draft can meet a numerical requirement while still needing attention to continuity, so check that the edits preserve the essential elements of your story.

Recheck the version you will submit

Use the final submission version for your last count. Even a small change to a title, note, or passage can make an earlier measurement outdated if that text belongs in the count. Select the required material again, check that it is complete, and compare the resulting total with the applicable range.

Review your working note alongside the draft: confirm the category and submission window, the text to include, and any counting method the magazine specifies. If you received clarification, apply it to the final measurement. Keep a note of the total and what you included so you can explain or reproduce your check if needed.

If the magazine’s submission process shows a count, compare it with your own. A difference is a prompt to investigate, not proof that either number measures the same selection of text. Check the content you entered, the accompanying material, and any instructions about counting. If the difference could put the story outside the permitted range and you cannot resolve it from the guidance, seek clarification before submitting.

Finally, make sure the text you send is the version you counted. If you make another edit during submission, repeat the relevant check. Once the final text and the magazine’s instructions agree, you can complete the submission with a clear record of how you arrived at your count.

A final check. Keep the original text and review transformed results in context before publishing.